Family-owned masonry & hardscape contractor serving greater Boston for over 30 years.245 Salem St, Woburn, MA · Mon–Fri 7am–5pm
Gerrior Masonry & Landscape
A French drain trench lined with filter fabric, perforated pipe and washed crushed stone running along a lawn
Landscape

Dry Well vs French Drain: Which One Fixes Your Wet Yard?

Dry well vs French drain: which fixes roof water, which fixes a soggy yard, how Massachusetts clay and ledge change the choice, and when to use both together.

By Gerrior Masonry & Landscape, Woburn, MAUpdated October 16, 20266 min read
On this page
  1. The short answer, by symptom
  2. What a dry well does
  3. What a French drain does
  4. Key differences
  5. Soil, ledge and groundwater north of Boston
  6. The combined system
  7. Before anyone digs
  8. What drives the cost
  9. When to call a drainage contractor
  10. Common questions

Dry well vs French drain comes down to what kind of water you have. A dry well is a place to put water you have already collected, usually roof water from a downspout. A French drain is a trench that collects water seeping through the soil along a line and carries it somewhere else. They solve different problems, and on many wet properties the best answer is both: a French drain that empties into a dry well.

Below is a quick way to match your symptom to the right system, then the details that decide it on a Massachusetts lot: soil, groundwater, ledge and where the water can go.

The short answer, by symptom

  • Downspouts dump water that runs back toward the house. A dry well, fed by a buried solid pipe from the downspout.
  • A soggy strip at the bottom of a slope, or ground that stays wet days after rain. A French drain (sometimes called a curtain drain) across the slope to catch the seeping water.
  • A low spot in the lawn that holds a puddle. First check whether regrading can let it drain. If not, a surface inlet or catch basin piped to a dry well, covered in our post on catch basins and dry wells.
  • Both roof water and a wet yard. A French drain that feeds a dry well, or runs out to daylight if the lot slopes enough.

What a dry well does

A dry well is a buried pit of clean stone, or a perforated chamber set in stone, that holds water and lets it soak slowly into the ground. It handles water that arrives in one place, such as a downspout or a catch basin. It does not collect water from the soil around it. Our dry well guide covers what a dry well is, sizing, depth, placement and dry well alternatives in detail.

A plastic dry well chamber being set into a deep hole in a yard with an inlet pipe from a downspout
A plastic dry well chamber being set into a deep hole in a yard with an inlet pipe from a downspout.

What a French drain does

A French drain is a trench lined with filter fabric, partly filled with clean washed stone, with a perforated pipe in the stone. Water in the soil finds the stone easier to move through than the ground around it, drops into the pipe, and runs downhill in the pipe to an outlet. The outlet can be daylight (a lower spot on your property where the pipe ends at the surface), a dry well, or, only where the town allows it, a storm drain.

The names overlap. A curtain drain is a French drain placed uphill of a problem area to intercept water before it arrives. A footing drain is a perforated pipe laid along the base of a foundation when the house is built. Our post on drainage around the house foundation covers footing drains.

Key differences

  • Water it handles. Dry well: water delivered to it in a pipe. French drain: water in the soil along its whole length.
  • Where water ends up. Dry well: in the ground, on your property. French drain: wherever its outlet is, which can be a dry well.
  • Soil. A dry well depends on the soil around it draining. A French drain to daylight depends more on having enough slope to an outlet.
  • Space. A dry well needs one spot, downhill and well away from the house. A French drain needs a continuous trench line.
  • Upkeep. Both last longer when silt and leaves are kept out: a leaf screen at the downspout, filter fabric around the stone, and an inspection port or cleanout to check them.

Soil, ledge and groundwater north of Boston

This is where the choice is often made for you. Much of the area around Woburn has clay, compacted fill or ledge (solid bedrock close to the surface), and many yards have groundwater that rises close to the surface in spring.

  • Sandy or gravelly soil: a dry well works well.
  • Clay or packed fill: a dry well takes water slowly. It may need to be larger, or the water may need to go to daylight instead.
  • Ledge: limits how deep anything can go. Sometimes a shallow French drain to daylight is the only practical answer.
  • High spring groundwater: a dry well sitting in groundwater has nowhere to send water. Its bottom has to stay above the seasonal high water table.

A simple test hole tells a lot. Dig where the dry well would go, fill the hole with water, and watch how fast it drains, ideally in spring when the ground is wettest. If it barely moves, a dry well alone is the wrong plan.

The combined system

On many lots the answer is one connected system: a French drain catches groundwater along a slope, a solid pipe carries it and the roof water past the house, and a dry well downhill takes it into the ground. An overflow lets the dry well spill safely to the surface in a storm bigger than it was sized for. Connecting the pieces in the right order, with silt kept out of the dry well, is what keeps it working.

Before anyone digs

  • In Massachusetts, state law requires notice to Dig Safe at least 72 hours before digging, not counting weekends and legal holidays (Dig Safe FAQ).
  • Keep dry wells and drain outlets away from a septic system, a private water well and property lines, and never send water onto a neighbor's lot.
  • Near wetlands or a stream, your town's Conservation Commission may need to review the work. See our post on dry well permits.

What drives the cost

Both systems are priced by the job, not by a standard number. The main factors are the length of trench or size of the well, how deep it has to go, the soil and any ledge, how far the water has to be piped, access for a small excavator, and what has to be restored afterward, such as lawn, plantings or a walkway. Our dry well guide explains these factors in more depth.

When to call a drainage contractor

Call when water is reaching the basement, when the yard stays wet for days, or when you are not sure whether the problem is roof water or groundwater. Gerrior installs French drains, dry wells, underground downspout piping and regrading, and repairs the foundation masonry that water has damaged. Owner Joseph Gerrior oversees the work. See our foundation and drainage repair page. A Reading customer wrote about one of our drainage jobs:

"Joe and his crew just finished up a drainage job for us. They were on time, great to work with (as usual) and the guys always friendly. They were very careful in the yard and Joe was excellent with the little excavator." Larry P., Reading, MA

Common questions

Can a French drain empty into a dry well?

Yes, and it is a common setup. Run solid pipe from the end of the French drain to the dry well, and keep silt out of the well so it doesn't clog.

Which lasts longer, a dry well or a French drain?

Either can last many years when it is built with clean stone and filter fabric and kept free of silt and leaves. Both fail early when dirt gets into the stone.

Does a dry well work in clay soil?

Poorly, in most cases. Clay takes water slowly, so the well fills and stays full. A larger well, more than one well, or a French drain to daylight may work better.

Can my sump pump drain into a dry well?

Sump pump discharge is often piped to a dry well. We handle the outside piping and the well. If you also need a sump pump installed or replaced, ask us whether that is part of your project.

Not sure which one your yard needs? We can walk the property, look at where the water comes from and recommend the simplest fix that will work. Gerrior Masonry & Landscape Construction Corp. is a family-owned company in Woburn, MA, with over 30 years in masonry and drainage work. We are fully insured, our work is guaranteed, and estimates are free. Call (781) 933-4157 or request a free estimate.

Gerrior Masonry & Landscape
Written by Gerrior Masonry & Landscape

A family-owned masonry and hardscape company at 245 Salem St, Woburn, MA, in business for over 30 years. See our hardscape work.

Keep reading

Have a project in mind? Start with a free estimate.

Office
245 Salem St, Woburn, MA
Hours
Mon–Fri 7am–5pm
Family-owned
Over 30 years
Coverage
Fully insured